Photonics Map

Photodiode, APD or PMT: which detector for your light level

A decision guide for the three detector families buyers compare most. The choice follows from how much light you have, what wavelength it is at, how fast you need to measure it and how large the active area must be. Not a supplier ranking.

Supplier directory · By Photonics Map · reviewed 2026-11

Si APD gain
50–1000 (RP Photonics)
Ge / InGaAs APD gain
10–40 (RP Photonics)
PMT gain
10⁶–10⁷ (Hamamatsu handbook)
Si photodiode range
roughly 400–1000 nm

Who this guide is for

Engineers and buyers specifying a detector for power measurement, fluorescence, ranging, spectroscopy or photon counting who need to decide between a PIN photodiode, an avalanche photodiode (APD) and a photomultiplier tube (PMT). It does not cover cameras, thermal detectors or terahertz detectors.

The three families in plain terms

A photodiode is a semiconductor p–n junction, often with an intrinsic layer (p–i–n), that turns absorbed photons into a photocurrent with no internal gain. An avalanche photodiode is a photodiode run at a high reverse voltage, typically tens or even hundreds of volts, so that carriers generate secondary carriers and the photocurrent is amplified inside the semiconductor. A photomultiplier tube is a vacuum tube: light frees electrons from a photocathode, and a chain of dynodes multiplies them. Gain rises in that order. Hamamatsu gives PMT gain as 10⁶ to 10⁷; RP Photonics gives silicon APD gain as 50 to 1000 and germanium or InGaAs APD gain as 10 to 40.

Decision table: photodiode vs APD vs PMT

Pulse regimes compared for buyer decisions
RegimePulseStrengthChoose when
Light levelPD bright · APD low · PMT lowestA p–i–n photodiode has no gain and responds linearly over six or more orders of magnitude (RP Photonics: a few nanowatts to tens of milliwatts for a silicon device with an area of a few mm²). An APD extends the detectable level by roughly an order of magnitude. A PMT can detect single photons.Signal is microwatts or more and you need to measure it: photodiode. Signal is too weak for the amplifier noise: APD. Photon counting at low rates: PMT, or an APD in Geiger mode.
Wavelengthset by material or photocathodePhotodiodes: Si roughly 400–1000 nm, Ge roughly 900–1600 nm, InGaAs roughly 900–1700 nm (RP Photonics). APDs: Si about 450–1000 nm, Ge and InGaAs up to roughly 1.7 μm. PMTs depend on the photocathode: Hamamatsu lists multialkali from the ultraviolet to about 850 nm and Ag-O-Cs from 400 to 1200 nm.Start from your wavelength and read the spectral response curve, not the headline range.
Speedall can reach GHz classPhotodiode bandwidth is limited by capacitance and transit time; tens of gigahertz needs an active diameter well below 1 mm (RP Photonics). APD bandwidth trades off against gain. PMT electron transit time is a few to tens of nanoseconds, and with optimized electrode designs rise time can be far below 1 ns.Fast pulses on a small beam: photodiode or APD. Fast pulses on a large area with low noise: PMT.
Active areaPMT largest at low noiseRP Photonics notes that a PMT combines a large active area with high bandwidth and low noise, whereas for a photodiode area and speed trade off through capacitance.Large diffuse sources such as scintillators or wide-field fluorescence: PMT. Fiber-coupled or focused beams: a small semiconductor detector is enough.
Calibration and stabilityPD best · APD and PMT need controlRP Photonics says APDs are hardly suitable for precise low-power measurement because their responsivity is not as well defined as a p–i–n diode's; gain depends strongly on reverse voltage and temperature, so APDs need a stabilized bias or temperature compensation. PMT gain also depends sensitively on a stable high voltage, typically of the order of 1 kV.Absolute optical power: photodiode. APD or PMT: budget for a low-noise bias supply and ask the supplier for the gain-versus-voltage curve.
Robustness and operationsemiconductors simplerRP Photonics says PMTs can be damaged by mechanical shock and by bright light such as daylight even when switched off, and that most designs are disturbed by magnetic fields well below 1 mT; microchannel-plate designs tolerate fields of several teslas. Silicon photomultipliers are more compact and robust than PMTs but have a much higher dark count rate per unit of active area at room temperature.Shock, daylight exposure or magnetic fields in the environment: check the PMT's tolerance, or consider a semiconductor detector. Fixed instrument with a dark enclosure and controlled fields: a PMT is practical.

How to choose

  1. 01

    Start from the light you actually have

    Estimate the optical power at the detector, not at the source. If it is well above what the front-end electronics can resolve, a p–i–n photodiode with a transimpedance amplifier is the simplest and best-defined choice. Only add gain when amplifier noise, not shot noise, limits the measurement. RP Photonics notes that an APD's gain helps most when electronic noise is the limit, and that its own multiplication noise can offset the advantage.

  2. 02

    Compare gain at the same wavelength

    Gain figures quoted for a family are ranges. The gain you get at your wavelength, with your bias, depends on the device. Ask for gain versus voltage and the excess noise factor for APDs, and cathode sensitivity versus wavelength for PMTs.

  3. 03

    Do not confuse quantum efficiency with detection efficiency

    RP Photonics warns that PMT datasheets almost always give the photocathode's quantum efficiency, which excludes collection losses, while some suppliers quote detection efficiency instead. Check which one a number is before comparing two PMTs or a PMT against an APD.

  4. 04

    Single photons are a different question

    APDs in Geiger mode reach dark count rates below 1 kHz and detection efficiency of several tens of percent, but a recovery time of around 100 ns limits count rate to the order of 10 MHz (RP Photonics, typical values). If counting is the job, read the single-photon detector category rather than choosing from this table.

How to shortlist suppliers

  1. 01

    Write the signal sheet

    Wavelength, pulse or continuous, optical power at the detector, required bandwidth, active area or beam diameter, operating temperature, and whether the environment has magnetic fields or bright ambient light.

  2. 02

    Ask for the same data from every supplier

    Spectral response at your wavelength, gain and bias range, dark current or dark count rate at your temperature, bandwidth or rise time, and the power supply and amplifier you need to add. A vendor figure describes that vendor's part only.

  3. 03

    Then browse suppliers

    Use the photodetector category to find companies and the single-photon category if counting is the job. Listing order is not a ranking of quality or suitability.

Ready to browse companies? Open the supplier hub.

Frequently asked questions

›What is the difference between a photodiode and an avalanche photodiode?

A photodiode produces about one electron per absorbed photon at best. An APD is operated at a high reverse voltage so that carriers multiply, which raises responsivity but adds multiplication noise and makes gain depend strongly on voltage and temperature (RP Photonics).

›When is a photomultiplier tube better than an APD?

When you need a large active area with low noise and high bandwidth. RP Photonics says PMTs typically offer a larger area and lower noise for that area, while APDs are more compact and robust.

›How much gain does each detector have?

A p–i–n photodiode has none. RP Photonics gives silicon APD gain as 50 to 1000 and germanium or InGaAs APD gain as 10 to 40. Hamamatsu's handbook gives PMT gain as 10⁶ to 10⁷.

›Which detector for the near infrared?

Silicon works to roughly 1000 nm. Beyond that, germanium and InGaAs photodiodes and APDs cover up to about 1.6 to 1.7 μm (RP Photonics). Hamamatsu lists an Ag-O-Cs photocathode sensitive from 400 to 1200 nm, but with lower sensitivity in the visible than other photocathodes.

›What is a silicon photomultiplier?

An array of many small avalanche diodes. RP Photonics says compared with PMT tubes they are more compact and robust and can have higher photon detection efficiency, but have a much higher dark count rate per micrometer of active area at room temperature.

Sources

Figures are the commercially common cases, not physics records. Where sources disagree the page gives a range and says so.

Photodiode vs APD vs PMT: Which Detector to Choose · Photonics Map