Femtosecond vs picosecond: when pico is enough
A regime-choice guide for micromachining and research: when picosecond clears the quality gate, when femtosecond earns its cost, and how to decide with shared sample metrics. Not a full architecture or RFQ-numbers guide.
Supplier directory · By Photonics Map · reviewed 2026-10
- Femtosecond pulse
- ≪ 1 ps (typically 10–900 fs)
- Picosecond pulse
- ~1 ps – tens of ps
- Shared class
- Ultrafast / ultrashort pulse
- Buyer axis
- HAZ and quality vs cost and average power
Who this guide is for
Process engineers, lab managers and micromachining buyers who already know they need an ultrashort pulse and are deciding between picosecond and femtosecond, not between ultrafast and nanosecond. For fiber vs solid state, OEM vs turnkey and supplier shortlisting, use the deep femtosecond guide. For sizing duration, wavelength and power on an RFQ after you pick a regime, use the choose-specs satellite.
Pulse duration in plain terms
A picosecond is 10⁻¹² s; a femtosecond is 10⁻¹⁵ s, about a thousand times shorter. RP Photonics defines picosecond lasers as sources with pulses typically between 1 ps and some tens of picoseconds, and femtosecond lasers as sources with pulses well below 1 ps (a few fs to hundreds of fs). Both sit under “ultrafast” or “ultrashort pulse” lasers. During a nanosecond pulse, heat can diffuse into the surrounding material; at roughly 10 ps or less, heat diffusion during the pulse is already minimal. Electron–lattice energy transfer typically takes tens of picoseconds, so femtosecond (and very short picosecond) pulses deposit energy mainly in the electron system first: the basis of “cold” ablation and a smaller heat-affected zone (HAZ).
Decision table: femtosecond vs picosecond
| Regime | Pulse | Strength | Choose when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heat-affected zone | fs smaller · ps still ≪ ns | Both limit thermal conduction vs nanosecond pulses. Femtosecond usually leaves the smallest HAZ; picosecond is already a large step down from ns for many metals and organics. | Edge quality, recast or microcracks would scrap the part: lean fs. A slightly larger HAZ is acceptable after process optimisation: ps is often enough. |
| Precision / edge quality | fs often finer · ps often enough | RP Photonics notes that micromachining sometimes achieves better quality with femtosecond pulses, while picosecond pulses are often sufficient when the overall process is well optimised. | Transparent or heat-sensitive workpieces, polymer stents, glass/sapphire cuts, or multiphoton processes: favour fs. Metals and many industrial features with a proven ps recipe: stay on ps. |
| Throughput / power | ps often higher $/W | Picosecond sources are often more economical: higher average output power is available at a lower price than comparable femtosecond systems (RP Photonics). | Parts per hour and Watt-class process windows dominate the business case: start with picosecond and only escalate if sample parts fail quality gates. |
| Cost and complexity | ps usually lower · fs usually higher | Shorter pulses generally mean more complex stretch–amplify–compress chains, tighter optics and higher list price. Factory uptime and service model often matter more than the last femtosecond. | Budget and service footprint are constrained and quality is already met on ps samples: do not buy fs. Quality fails on ps despite process work: budget for fs. |
| Materials | fs for nonlinear / fragile · ps for many metals | High peak intensity of ultrashort pulses enables multiphoton absorption in transparent materials (glass, sapphire). That nonlinear path is most reliable in the femtosecond regime for many display and optics processes. | Inside-glass cuts, filamentation/Bessel delivery, or heat-sensitive polymers: plan on fs. Opaque metals and organics with an established ps process window: ps first. |
How to choose
- 01
When picosecond is enough
Choose picosecond when you need ultrafast quality versus nanosecond, the material is not forcing a nonlinear or ultra-low-HAZ path, and sample parts meet edge and yield targets after normal process optimisation. RP Photonics explicitly notes that picosecond lasers are often preferred in micromachining when they are sufficient, because they are typically more cost-effective and can deliver higher average power for the price. Many metal micromachining and industrial texturing lines sit here.
- 02
When you need femtosecond
Choose femtosecond when picosecond samples still show unacceptable HAZ, recast, chipping or cracking; when you must machine inside transparent media via nonlinear absorption; or when the application is inherently fs (multiphoton microscopy, two-photon polymerisation, many ophthalmic and polymer medical cuts). Pay for the regime that clears your quality gate, not for the shortest pulse on the brochure.
- 03
Decide with samples, not slogans
Run the same feature on ps and fs demo systems (or a job shop) with shared metrics. If ps clears the gate at lower capital and operating cost, stop there. Escalate to fs only with a failed quality or materials reason written down.
How to shortlist suppliers
- 01
Write the process sheet first
Material, feature geometry, maximum acceptable HAZ or chipping, target throughput, and whether the beam must work inside a transparent workpiece. That sheet decides regime before brand.
- 02
Shortlist both regimes only if quality is open
If your process sheet already forces nonlinear glass work or proven fs medical cuts, skip ps demos. If quality is open, ask two ps and one fs vendor (or one job shop with both) against the same metrics.
- 03
After you pick a regime, read the matching guide
If you need fs architectures, applications and supplier shortlisting, open the deep femtosecond guide. If you need to size pulse duration, wavelength and power for the RFQ, open the choose-specs satellite. Then use the supplier hub to browse companies.
Ready to browse companies? Open the supplier hub.
Frequently asked questions
›Are femtosecond lasers always better than picosecond lasers?
No. For some applications femtosecond systems achieve higher quality, but picosecond lasers are often more cost-effective (higher average power for a lower price) and are sufficient when the process is well optimised (RP Photonics). Buy the shortest pulse you can justify with sample parts, not the shortest pulse available.
›How much shorter is a femtosecond pulse than a picosecond pulse?
One picosecond is 10⁻¹² s; one femtosecond is 10⁻¹⁵ s. A 300 fs pulse is about three times shorter than 1 ps and about a thousand times shorter than 300 ps. Commercial bands overlap near 1 ps; treat the datasheet number and the duration at the workpiece as separate questions.
›Why do ultrashort pulses reduce the heat-affected zone?
Energy is delivered faster than heat can diffuse into the surrounding material during the pulse. At roughly 10 ps or less, heat diffusion during the pulse is already minimal compared with nanosecond pulses. Femtosecond pulses also couple efficiently into nonlinear absorption in transparent materials, which longer pulses often cannot.
›Can I upgrade from picosecond to femtosecond later?
Sometimes the scanner, motion and fixturing transfer; the laser head and often the process recipe do not. If you expect to need fs within a year, compare total cost of a ps line plus a later fs head against buying fs once. Ask integrators what actually ports.
›Does burst mode change the fs vs ps decision?
Burst mode groups pulses to raise ablation rate for some materials while managing residual heat. It is available on many industrial ultrafast sources in both regimes. It can close a throughput gap, but it does not replace a regime change when HAZ or transparent-material physics is the real limit.
›Where do I go after I choose a regime?
Use the deep femtosecond guide for architectures and shortlisting if you need fs, and the choose-specs satellite to write duration, wavelength and power on the RFQ. Browse the femtosecond supplier hub for companies listing fs or ultrafast systems. Picosecond-only products are a separate category on the site when you need that shortlist.
Sources
- RP Photonics Encyclopedia: Picosecond lasers · definition (~1 ps to tens of ps); economy vs fs; micromachining sufficiency
- RP Photonics Encyclopedia: Femtosecond lasers · definition (well below 1 ps); ultrafast class shared with picosecond
- RP Photonics Encyclopedia: Ultrafast lasers · umbrella term for picosecond and femtosecond sources
- RP Photonics Encyclopedia: Laser ablation · thermal conduction vs pulse length; electron–lattice timescales; HAZ; multiphoton absorption in transparent materials
Figures are the commercially common cases, not physics records. Where sources disagree the page gives a range and says so.