Silicon photonics and other PIC platforms: what each does well
A decision guide for choosing a photonic integrated circuit (PIC) platform. Each material solves some problems and not others, so the choice follows from the functions your chip needs, the wavelengths it works at and how it will be packaged. Not a ranking of companies.
Supplier directory · By Photonics Map · reviewed 2026-11
- Silicon
- CMOS compatible, dense; poor light emitter
- Indium phosphide
- lasers, modulators, detectors on one chip
- Silicon nitride
- very low loss, visible to mid-IR
- Lithium niobate
- fast modulators, frequency conversion
Who this guide is for
Engineers and buyers scoping a PIC for communications, sensing, LIDAR or quantum work who need to decide which material platform to ask suppliers and foundries about. It does not cover chip design, foundry process-design kits or pricing.
PICs and silicon photonics in plain terms
A photonic integrated circuit is a chip-scale device that integrates several optical components on one substrate: passive parts such as waveguides, couplers, filters and splitters, and often active parts such as lasers, modulators, amplifiers and photodetectors. Silicon photonics is one PIC platform. It builds the circuit on silicon, usually with silicon-on-insulator, and uses the CMOS manufacturing of the microelectronics industry. Other platforms use fused silica, silica on silicon, indium phosphide, silicon nitride or lithium niobate. RP Photonics' point is that no platform is ideal in every respect, so a hybrid of two platforms is sometimes needed.
Decision table: which PIC platform for which job
| Platform | Best at | Strength | Choose when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Silicon (silicon photonics) | dense circuits with electronics | Tight confinement and small bends allow dense circuits, and CMOS compatibility allows co-integration with electronics. Silicon emits light very inefficiently, so lasers usually come from InP or other III–V parts. | You need many components on one chip, co-integration with electronics or high-volume wafer production, and you can accept an external or bonded laser. Ask how detection at 1.3 and 1.5 μm is done (RP Photonics names SiGe and germanium-on-silicon routes). |
| Indium phosphide (InP) | all-in-one active integration | A direct-bandgap material, so one chip can hold lasers, amplifiers, modulators and detectors. Costlier to fabricate than silicon. | The chip must generate light itself and you want a single-material solution rather than a hybrid with a silicon chip. |
| Silicon nitride (Si₃N₄) | low loss, wide wavelength range | Broad transparency from the visible to the mid-infrared, very low propagation loss and suitability for high-Q resonators, with moderate index contrast. | Loss, visible wavelengths or high-Q resonators matter more than density. Particularly low losses matter for quantum PICs. |
| Lithium niobate (LiNbO₃) | fast modulators and frequency conversion | Strong electro-optic effect and nonlinearity give fast, linear modulators and frequency conversion. Birefringence makes polarization-independent designs hard. | Modulator speed and linearity or nonlinear frequency conversion is the main job, and polarization can be managed. |
| Fused silica and silica on silicon | passive, low loss, easy fiber coupling | Low loss for passive parts such as splitters and filters, and easy fiber coupling. Low index contrast means large bends and large circuits. | The circuit is mostly passive, and easy fiber coupling matters more than circuit size. |
How to choose
- 01
Start from the functions the chip must perform
List what has to happen on the chip: generate light, modulate it, detect it, split or filter it. RP Photonics' device-implementability criterion is the one that most often excludes a platform: lithium niobate suits electro-optics and frequency conversion, which are difficult or impossible in silica, and silicon cannot emit light efficiently. Pick candidate platforms by function first.
- 02
Then check wavelength
Transparency window is the other hard constraint. Silicon is transparent from about 1.1 μm into the far infrared, and its photodiodes normally stop at about 1.1 μm. Silicon nitride is described as transparent from the visible to the mid-infrared. Match the platform to your operating wavelengths before comparing anything else.
- 03
Plan the light source and the coupling early
If you choose silicon, decide how the laser gets onto or into the package: bonded III–V gain, an external fiber-coupled laser diode, or another route. RP Photonics notes that coupling a ≈10 μm mode field fiber to a sub-0.5 μm silicon waveguide is a significant challenge. Edge coupling gives low insertion loss, often below 1 dB, but allows testing only after dicing, while grating couplers allow wafer-level testing but typically have higher loss and narrower bandwidth.
- 04
Budget for packaging, not only the chip
RP Photonics calls packaging one of the most complex and costly challenges in integrated photonics: sub-micron alignment tolerances, thermal management, high-frequency electrical routing, testing, and a lack of industry-wide standards. Ask suppliers early what packaging and testing they provide and what they leave to you.
How to shortlist suppliers
- 01
Write the function and wavelength sheet
Operating wavelength range, required functions on chip, insertion loss budget, modulation bandwidth, footprint and polarization sensitivity. RP Photonics' buyer's guide for silicon photonics lists device type, wavelength range, insertion loss, coupling mechanism, modulation bandwidth, footprint, polarization sensitivity and thermal tuning power as the selection criteria.
- 02
Ask each supplier the same questions
Which platform and which foundry, how the light source is integrated, how fiber coupling is done and whether the chip can be tested at wafer level, what packaging is included, and which figures were measured rather than designed. A supplier's figure describes that supplier's chip only.
- 03
Then browse suppliers
Use the integrated photonics category to find companies and the photonic packaging category if assembly is the bottleneck. Listing order is not a ranking of quality or suitability.
Ready to browse companies? Open the supplier hub.
Frequently asked questions
›What is the difference between silicon photonics and a photonic integrated circuit?
A photonic integrated circuit is any chip that integrates multiple optical components on one substrate. Silicon photonics is one way to make it: on silicon, using CMOS-style manufacturing (RP Photonics). Other platforms use indium phosphide, silicon nitride, lithium niobate or silica.
›Why can't silicon make a laser?
Silicon has an indirect band gap, which makes it a very inefficient light emitter. RP Photonics says silicon-based laser and amplifier performance cannot compete with gallium arsenide or indium phosphide approaches, so silicon chips usually get light from a bonded III–V gain chip, a germanium-on-silicon laser, or an external fiber-coupled laser diode.
›How is light modulated in silicon?
Silicon has no χ(2) nonlinearity, so it cannot make electro-optic modulators in the usual way. Instead, injecting carriers changes the refractive index, used in Mach–Zehnder interferometers and micro-ring resonators; RP Photonics says bandwidths of multiple gigabits per second can be reached, and that germanium-on-silicon electroabsorption modulators are another option.
›Can silicon detect telecom wavelengths?
Not on its own. A silicon photodiode is normally sensitive only below about 1.1 μm. Detection at 1.3 or 1.5 μm uses silicon–germanium alloys or other approaches, with lattice mismatch as a problem to manage (RP Photonics).
›What is co-packaged optics?
An arrangement where silicon photonic transmitter and receiver engines share a package with a network switch chip or processor. RP Photonics says the short electrical connections can reduce interconnect power and support high aggregate bandwidth, but make attachment, thermal management, testing and repairability particularly important.
Sources
- RP Photonics Encyclopedia: Silicon photonics · CMOS compatibility; indirect band gap; no χ(2); modulators; detectors; coupling methods; co-packaged optics
- RP Photonics Encyclopedia: Photonic integrated circuits · platform comparison (silica, silicon, InP, silicon nitride, lithium niobate); circuit complexity; packaging; applications; foundry model
Figures are the commercially common cases, not physics records. Where sources disagree the page gives a range and says so.